Noah Presgrove, a 19-year-old recent graduate, was found deceased on Labor Day 2023 along a remote stretch of US-81 in Jefferson County, Oklahoma. Nearly a year later, newly released 911 calls shed light on the unsettling scene witnessed by two individuals the morning after.

Presgrove was last seen alive at a party with friends before being discovered with fatal blunt-force injuries. Two motorists initially mistook his body for a deer on the roadside, prompting calls to emergency services.

One caller reported, "It looks like someone may have been hit, lying on the shoulder of the road. At first, I thought it was a deer, but it appears to be a body," describing the scene as "highly unusual."

Minutes later, another witness reported a similar discovery to 911, stating, "I believe there's a deceased person lying naked on the side of the road," noting additional clothing nearby.

Authorities initially deemed Presgrove's death suspicious but later categorized it as undetermined, citing multiple blunt force injuries consistent with an ATV accident earlier that night. His family, seeking closure, has emphasized their belief in an accidental scenario, expressing no hostility towards anyone potentially involved.

"I can't imagine someone intentionally harming Noah," said Madison Rawlings, Presgrove's sister, advocating for clarity through the "Justice for Noah Presgrove" campaign on Facebook.